MacNN | Hands on: PowerTrekk portable fuel cell charger
Mac News Network View: Standard | Headlines | Categorized | Slim
Mac News Network
Mac News iPod News Reviews Forums
 

Desktop Headlines
Hands on: PowerTrekk portable fuel cell charger
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 1:46pm

MyFC made headlines two years ago when it unveiled a portable fuel cell charger, the PowerTrekk, however the promise of a spring 2012 release has now turned into a spring 2013 target. We were surprised to see the company at the Macworld expo this week, after passing off the concept as a good idea that wasn't ready for the market, so we decided to stop by the booth to take a second look at the unique technology and reconsider its practicality.



The PowerTrekk charger takes advantage of the same concept utilized in prototype fuel-cell vehicles, producing electricity through a chemical reaction between hydrogen and oxygen. The portable system requires single-use "pucks" to separate the necessary hydrogen from water, which is added by the user. The company promotes the technology as a competitor to solar, eliminating the need to maintain optimum sunlight exposure, and without the gradual degradation of batteries. Both points may be true, but we can't think of a realistic scenario in which the 10- to 15-year shelf life of typical batteries becomes a limiting factor. For the ultralight backpacker, paying $100 for a few titanium pans and cutting the handle off a toothbrush is worth a few grams of weight reduction. The PowerTrekk pucks do feel very light, at 33 grams, and contain four watt-hours of energy, but this is nearly identical to the power-to-weight ratio for a 24-gram AA-size lithium-ion battery with 3.1 watt-hours of energy. The PowerTrekk charger also contains its own lithium-polymer battery, providing 5.6 Wh of primary power before needing to switch to a puck when away from an AC outlet. MyFC's technology is certainly unique, particularly in a portable form, but it still appears to be suffering the same setbacks that have plagued automotive fuel-cell implementation. Despite years of advancements and lower costs for fuel-cell technology, car manufacturers are continuing to push back their plans for commercialization. Many analysts view the technology as pointless and impractical in cars, which are arguably better suited to the higher efficiencies of battery storage. Getting back to the PowerTrekk, we have the same doubts about the practicality of fuel cells as a portable charging solution. Anyone off-the-grid can spend $4 for a single throw-away puck (on top of the $229 price of the charger itself), or $4 for a pair of rechargeable lithium-ion batteries that offer a comparable power-to-weight ratio, higher capacity and in a smaller package. The pucks also can't be restarted, wasting the rest of the puck if a device or the internal battery is simply being topped off, and the listed operating temperature starts at 41 degrees fahrenheit. Adding to the list of limiting factors, the company strongly warns against using the charger in a pocket, in a backpack or even covered with cloth. Portable fuel-cell doesn't make sense to us, and we can't imagine it makes much sense to many other potential buyers. We could say that we're optimistic about improvements and marketability in the near future, but we've been hearing that broken promise from car companies for decades.

Comments on this Article
Print Friendly Version
Email to a Friend
Add MacNN to Your RSS Feeds
Buy from the Apple Store


Related Stories:

Today's MacNN Stories:

  • Forums: Yosemite pros and cons - 2:24 PM EST
  • Apple deals: Up to $710 off refurbished rMBPs - 2:21 PM EST
  • DealNN: Mac mini for $490 - 2:19 PM EST
  • Sapphire production insufficient for iPhone 6 displays, analysts say - 1:43 PM EST
  • Trouble at TPK may hint at iWatch production issues - 12:35 PM EST
  • MOTU ships trio of Thunderbolt audio interfaces, AVB Ethernet switch - 12:04 PM EST
  • CNBC, Fox Now added to US Apple TV lineup - 11:23 AM EST
  • Briefly: Total War: Shogun 2, SilhouetteFX 5.2 - 10:35 AM EST
  • Refurbished Retina MacBook Pros drop below $1,000 mark - 10:27 AM EST
  • AppleCare+ plans for iPhone, iPad come to Mexico and Sweden - 9:11 AM EST
  • Drobo Mini ships with included SSD storage for portable storage - 9:01 AM EST
  • Apple updates MacBook pro line with faster processors, more RAM - 8:30 AM EST
  • Canon unveils PowerShot SX520 HS, SX400 IS bridge cameras - 5:57 AM EST
  • Briefly: Yelp adds video, Facebook forces Messenger for iOS - 2:07 AM EST
  • Apple Stores gearing up to allow early-upgrade carrier program buying? - 12:43 AM EST

    Today's iPodNN Stories:
  • Microsoft reportedly plans two more imminent Lumia launches - 2:18 PM EST
  • Electronic Arts deploying EA Access Xbox One game subscription program - 1:21 PM EST
  • Chen's BlackBerry acquires German security firm Secusmart - 12:48 PM EST
  • LG commences pre-orders for 105-inch curved Ultra HD television - 12:02 PM EST
  • UK police at all traffic accidents seizing cellphones, seeking fault - 11:59 AM EST
  • No comments posted on this story yet. Please post yours.
    Your Comments
    In order to post comments, you must be a registered member of the MacNN Forums and logged in. Please login with your MacNN Forums username and password.

    MacNN Forums Login:

    MacNN Forums Password:

    Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.