MacNN | Apple cites FRAND ruling to ITC, calls Samsung behavior 'egregious'
Mac News Network View: Standard | Headlines | Categorized | Slim
Mac News Network
Mac News iPod News Reviews Forums

Desktop Headlines
Apple cites FRAND ruling to ITC, calls Samsung behavior 'egregious'
Thursday, May 23, 2013 @ 4:23pm

Apple has wasted no time filing with the US International Trade Commission (ITC) regarding the landmark ruling from May 22 enjoining a standards essential patent holder from enforcing a potential ITC-ordered sales embargo. Apple's filing with the court summarizes Judge White's decision, and calls Samsung's conduct "even more egregious" than that of the cited case's patent holder.

Apple said in the filing with the ITC that "the Realtek case is strikingly similar to the instant case. Samsung brought an ITC complaint before making any offer specific to its declared-essential patents, let alone a FRAND-compliant offer. Just as in Realtek, when Apple responded to the ITC complaint by requesting that Samsung provide FRAND terms for the specific asserted patents, Samsung responded by making a non-FRAND demand based on the total price of the accused Apple products--rather than the cost of the relevant accused components." "Indeed, Samsung's conduct here is even more egregious," Apple concludes, adding "in short, just as in Realtek, Samsung's pursuit of an ITC exclusion order directly conflicts with its FRAND commitments." Patent analyst Florian Mueller believes that the quoted case's patent owner refusing to make any licensing offer was key to the previous decision, making the judge decide that "this attempt to seek to gain unfair leverage must be thwarted." Apple never sought a fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) determination action like the alleged patent abuser did in the quoted case after Samsung's high patent license offer, which may be problematic to Apple's case. The ITC ruling is expected on May 31. The landmark ruling is the second item this week that the ITC has to consider in a relatiely last-minute fashion, with the other item being the letter by US senators reminding the ITC of FRAND patent value to the US.

Comments on this Article
Print Friendly Version
Email to a Friend
Add MacNN to Your RSS Feeds
Buy from the Apple Store

Related Stories:

Today's MacNN Stories:
  • TD Canada Trust briefly lists cards that support Apple Pay - 4:00 PM EST
  • Forums: new iMacs, El Capitan comments and more - 3:46 PM EST
  • Apple deals: up to $180 off MacBook Air - 3:37 PM EST
  • Daily Deals: $65 Brother printer, 50-inch HDTV, Disney Infinity 3.0 - 1:57 PM EST
  • App Update (OS X): White Noise, WiFi Signal, Disk Diet, more - 1:41 PM EST
  • Scottrade, 28 others sign on to support Apple Pay - 1:00 PM EST
  • Tag Heuer CEO praises Apple Watch popularity, dismisses luxury pricing - 12:57 PM EST
  • Apple updates iMovie for Mac to handle 1080p slo-mo, 4K video - 12:14 PM EST
  • MacNN Deals: Turn your house into a smart home with these offers - 11:29 AM EST
  • Living with: watchOS 2 - 10:53 AM EST
  • Apple ships Magic Mouse 2, Magic Trackpad 2, Magic Keyboard - 9:33 AM EST
  • Retina 5K iMac upgraded with P3 color gamut, Skylake processors - 9:15 AM EST
  • Apple 21.5-inch 4K iMac finally arrives with Broadwell processors - 9:01 AM EST
  • Apple, US to judge: no need for further e-book anti-trust monitoring - 8:16 AM EST
  • Giveaway: Win an Apple iPhone 6s with MacNN Deals - 8:14 AM EST
  • Hands On: Day One 1.17.4 (Apple Watch) - 7:51 AM EST
  • Canon unveils EOS M10, PowerShot G9 X, G5 X cameras - 7:38 AM EST
  • The MacNN Podcast, episode 36: Macphun schway - 3:00 AM EST

    Today's iPodNN Stories:
  • So long, and thanks for everything! - 2:31 PM EST
  • Lizard Squad member convicted over 50,700 computer crime charges - 9:58 AM EST
  • Microsoft offers grants to universities for HoloLens research - 7:25 AM EST
  • LG Display starts mass production of AIT display panels for notebooks - 7:47 AM EST
  • Briefly: EE fined £1M in UK, Unofficial YouTube app on Android Wear - 11:14 AM EST
  • No comments posted on this story yet. Please post yours.
    Your Comments
    In order to post comments, you must be a registered member of the MacNN Forums and logged in. Please login with your MacNN Forums username and password.

    MacNN Forums Login:

    MacNN Forums Password:

    Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.