MacNN | Yelp ordered by Virginian court to unmask negative reviewer group
Mac News Network View: Standard | Headlines | Categorized | Slim
Mac News Network
Mac News iPod News Reviews Forums
 

Desktop Headlines
Yelp ordered by Virginian court to unmask negative reviewer group
Monday, January 13, 2014 @ 2:09pm

Yelp must reveal the identities of several users that posted negative comments about a business, a US court has decided. The Virginia Court of Appeals sided with Hadeed Carpet Cleaning, and demands that the details for a group of anonymous users on the review service must be revealed, with Yelp claiming the ruling "fails to adequately protect free speech rights on the Internet."



Lawyers working on behalf of Joe Hadeed, owner of Hadeed Carpet Cleaning, requested the identities of seven negative reviewers, reports the BBC, with the main reasoning being that he believed them not to be genuine customers, and therefore do not receive First Amendment protection. In a statement, the judge agreed that "Generally, a Yelp review is entitled to First Amendment protection because it is a person's opinion about a business that they patronized," and that users have the right to anonymously discuss services online without worrying about identification over disagreeable commentary. The judge does clarify that "If the reviewer was never a customer of the business, then the review is not an opinion; instead the review is based on a false statement," and therefore does not receive such anonymous protections.

Speaking on behalf of Yelp, spokesperson Vince Sollitto claimed that the US had "adopted strong protections in order to prevent online speech from being stifled by those upset with what was being said," though the company hopes for Virginia to follow the lead of other states in adopting such measures. "We are disappointed that the Virginia Court of Appeals has issued a ruling that fails to adequately protect free speech rights on the Internet, and which allows businesses to seek personal details about website users – without any evidence of wrongdoing – in efforts to silence online critics." Such a decision by the courts could have a chilling effect on future Yelp reviews, which could leave some users wary of leaving negative reviews in future, for fear of being identified and being sued over their comments. According to the company blog, Yelp plans to appeal the ruling, and to "continue to fight for the protection and expansion of free speech for all Internet users." Yelp came under fire in May last year over its reviews, with reports of reviews for businesses being hidden from view in order to benefit the service directly, such as removing negative reviews in order to attract advertisers. Yelp refuted the claims.

Comments on this Article
Print Friendly Version
Email to a Friend
Add MacNN to Your RSS Feeds
Buy from the Apple Store


Related Stories:

Today's MacNN Stories:
  • Hands On: Stray Dog Simulator 1.1 (iOS) - 7:37 AM EST
  • Apple issues fifth OS X 10.11 El Capitan to developers - 9:50 PM EST
  • Leak claims Parallels 11 will allow OS X users access to Cortana - 8:21 PM EST
  • Rumor: 10 million signed up for Apple Music in first month - 8:16 PM EST
  • Google separating Google Accounts, YouTube profiles from Google+ - 7:26 PM EST
  • Briefly: Apple joins WH climate group, announces UK bond sale - 5:00 PM EST
  • Follow-up: Apple to launch 500 new resellers in India - 3:06 PM EST
  • Daily Deals: Harman Kardon home theater, dashcam, Crucial 500GB SSD - 2:49 PM EST
  • Hands On: Busy Shapes 1.4.0 (iOS) - 1:40 PM EST
  • App Update: Deliver, uBar, Drobo Dashboard, more - 1:30 PM EST
  • The MacNN Podcast, episode 25: My Stupid Cat's Fault - 1:27 PM EST
  • Intel Skylake may offer 30 percent battery improvements over Broadwell - 12:34 PM EST
  • MacNN's Week that Was: July 19 through July 25, 2015 - 12:22 PM EST
  • Researchers develop single-molecule transistor in the lab - 10:55 AM EST
  • MacNN Deals: Three ways to upgrade how you charge USB devices - 10:30 AM EST
  • Beijing police raid counterfeit Apple iPhone maker, nine arrested - 10:18 AM EST
  • Pandora expands ad-based Sponsored Listening program - 10:03 AM EST
  • Hands On: Adventure Time Puzzle Quest 1.3.498317 (iOS) - 9:30 AM EST
  • Pointers: Text Expansion in Microsoft Word 2011 and 2016 - 9:26 AM EST
  • Comcast will test 10Gbps connection technology in fourth quarter - 9:13 AM EST
  • Apple, Nike agree to FuelBand suit settlement, Apple paying nothing - 8:32 AM EST
  • Living With: Fallout Shelter (iOS) - 7:31 AM EST
  • Best Buy starting Apple Watch sales in 100 stores from August 7 - 6:40 AM EST
  • Game Replay: Steam security issue, Nintendo ending TVii - 5:55 AM EST

    Today's iPodNN Stories:
  • So long, and thanks for everything! - 2:31 PM EST
  • Lizard Squad member convicted over 50,700 computer crime charges - 9:58 AM EST
  • Microsoft offers grants to universities for HoloLens research - 7:25 AM EST
  • LG Display starts mass production of AIT display panels for notebooks - 7:47 AM EST
  • Briefly: EE fined £1M in UK, Unofficial YouTube app on Android Wear - 11:14 AM EST
  • No comments posted on this story yet. Please post yours.
    Your Comments
    In order to post comments, you must be a registered member of the MacNN Forums and logged in. Please login with your MacNN Forums username and password.

    MacNN Forums Login:

    MacNN Forums Password:

    Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.